November 28th, 2011
|01:02 pm - The Last Werewolf|
I have just read The Last Werewolf by Glen Duncan. This is a British horror novel, which made the NY Times 100 Books of the year.
It's a straight-forward adventure style story, with a very hokey premise. The background is the deathly rivalry between Werewolves and Vampires (which I think is a recent Hollywood invention), and a secret society which hunts down supernatural beings ('World Organisation for the Control of Occult Phenomena' hmmph). The story is simple, with quite a lot of sex and violence, none of it too extreme. The protagonist is an action-hero James Bond type, staying in flashy hotels and drinking expensive alcohol.
Two aspects elevate it well above the Dan Brown basement of schlock novels. One is that Duncan has a reasonable grasp of politics, history and psychology. I don't mean it's marked by uniquely conceived insights or anything, but it's not offensively stupid like so many action stories are. For a story with quite a lot of sex, most of it with prostitutes, the portrayal of women was not offensive either. Furthermore, in stories like this the creature is sometimes sentimentalised - made to kill only people like Nazis, whom the novelist thinks deserve it for example - but I think this story manages to strike a reasonable balance, not over-sympathetic. Reading back through this paragraph it sounds like I am damning with faint praise, but to be honest I think it's a real achievement to write a populist rollicking novel which isn't as dumb as the rocks.
The other feature which elevates it above the baseline is that at a sentence level it is written in a fairly elaborate and assured style. Big vocabulary, diverse literary and philosophical references, original metaphors. Some might find it over-written or pretentious. Personally I am happy with this style. Here is a paragraph taken more or less at random to illustrate what I mean:
Reader, I ate him. About three hours after resolving that I wouldn't. Throughout the dull solo feast the refrain from Tennyson's Mariana repeated in the hot spaces of my gorging head:
She only said my life is dreary, he cometh not she said
She said, I am aweary, I would that I were dead.
I guess that is something you either like or not. I like it fine. This book is first of a trilogy. I will read #2 when it comes out, and I also expect this one day to be a pretty good film franchise.
Haven't read the book, but I did read Duncan's review
of Colson Whitehead's Zone One
in the NYT. Which put me off reading anything by him ever again.
Oh, he's the 'intellectual dating a porn star' guy! I think that metaphor is stupid, and the idea it expresses is plain wrong. But it seems to me that the rest of the review expresses a completely different idea: that it's perfectly appropriate and sensible to use a literary style to write a genre novel. And there's an obvious parallel with his own project. I would say, ignore the first two paragraphs of that review and see if you agree with the rest.
ETA - sorry, that sounds dumb. Obviously you have read the whole thing, what I meant was 'if you suppress the negative feelings arising from the first two paragraphs' because personally I never got past those last time
I didn't care much for the rest of the review either. The central point you cite is a valid one, but it's also an obvious one and the necessity that literary writers feel in stressing it just annoys me - as if they feel the need to emphasize that, obviously, one would think that there's something wrong with writing a genre novel, but here's why it's not. Plus, all those digs at genre fans really put my back up.
I believe that the "fur against fang" tradition was invented by the White Wolf role-playing-games universe.
Right, that makes sense. I think it's a weak idea for a book with this approach. It feels new and fake compared to the werewolf story which is old.
|Date:||November 28th, 2011 05:06 pm (UTC)|| |
"Reader, I ate him" is a fantastic line.
That's the kind of thing he does a lot throughout. It's less heavy handed than 'Pride and Prejudice and Zombies' and the like.