Then answer my questions three:
Sherlock Holmes would look like that
No Way
8(57.1%)
Way
6(42.9%)
Yum!
Affirmed
8(53.3%)
Denied
7(46.7%)
Contribution to canon
Unredeemable travesty
3(21.4%)
Not proper Sherlock, but worth seeing
6(42.9%)
Valid reinterpretation of the source material
5(35.7%)
ETA - I keep changing my answers
ETA a bit more - You know Doctor Watson is Jude Law?