Communicator (communicator) wrote,


This was an excellent episode. Every long running show has to have an episode where the characters are cooped up together and end up revealing things about themselves. It's called the 'Elevator episode' or something. An Elevator Episode must rely on a good script, good acting, and minimum effects. I always like them, they are a real favourite, and I thought this was an excellent example.

I was also slightly reminded of The Thing. And that made me think all the way through that the humans were right, and the Doctor was wrong. Val, or whatever she was called, the horrible mother (are there any other kind for RTD - sorry) was a bit like Mrs Bennett in P&P: ridiculous in every way except for being ruthlessly right. Like Ash bringing John Hurt on board the Nostromo, you shouldn't let the alien through the air lock, even if it's fixed to your friend.

I need to quote calapine (hope you don't mind) "The terror, my very favourite kind: cheap and claustrophobic. Scenes so wonderfully long. I mean, it's a bloody stageplay and OH HOW I ADORE IT." Well said, it was very stagey, and David Tennant did an excellent job.

I'll probably think of more in a minute.
  • Post a new comment


    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic