?

Log in

No account? Create an account
Surface Detail - The Ex-Communicator

> Recent Entries
> Archive
> Friends
> Profile

November 6th, 2010


Previous Entry Share Next Entry
12:02 pm - Surface Detail
I just listened on audio to Surface Detail, the new Culture novel by Iain M Banks. It's a complex story, and it's also written with imaginative and exuberant elaboration, as the title implies. I think densely written books work well on audio - The Children's Book by AS Byatt for example is one of my favourites. This was well read too, with warm and funny characterisation. I have to laugh sometimes at the descriptions of voices in SF stories - I imagine the face of the actor as he reads through for the first time, realising he will have to characterise, by voice alone, (for example) a talking chandelier described as 'soft and tinkling', a vocal vagina on the shaft of a vast disembodied penis, and a vicious argument between a whole room full of squeaky-voiced elf-things. LOL. He did a great job.

I don't always like Banks' books, but this one is the top rank in my opinion. I think some of his SF novels - Excession and the Algebraist for example - have a flaw in the centre, which undermines their impact. This one seems to be sound (I can't say wholesome) right through. Though admittedly I didn't grasp every nuance of the plot - the motives of the non-fallen bamboolean or whatever it was called remain opaque to me. But if one or more cultures are said to be superhumanly devious in strategy, it falls upon the writer to portray an appropriately devious strategy unfolding. As far as I can tell on one listen, this succeeds, with a story complex enough to rather confound me, but comprehensible enough to give each scene emotional impact.

The underlying premise of this story is one mentioned in previous Culture novels but not deeply explored - that at high levels of technology it will be possible to record a person's mental state, and then re-vent that person into a new body, or to run their personality within a simulated virtual realm. This could be done to give people a second life after death, or for strategic reasons.

Some people by the way, in our real world I mean, have argued that we can all look forward to blissful afterlives, courtesy of our descendants, who will rescue us in this way at the very end of history. For real.

I hadn't previously considered the issue raised in this book, which is that technologically advanced societies can be gripped by unpleasant religious convictions (not mentioning any names) and might rather use such technology to punish the undeserving by running eternal simulated hells in which billions of souls experience unmitigated suffering. Great, another thing to worry about: 'the dread of something after death, the undiscovered country from whose bourne no traveller returns', instigated by the Sarah Palin of the 299th century. But never fear - the truly civilised would never countenance torture, and goodies always win wars, don't they?

It is not a spoiler to say that various philosophical issues and interesting circumstances raised by the duplication of minds are explored in this novel, nor that the obscenity of hell, and the drive to put a stop to it as quickly as possible, gives the plotty shenanigans their emotional propulsion. I was out walking, listening to a particularly harrowing scene, and I found I had my fingers crossed so hard it actually hurt. As if that would help.

There are at least two issues that this book made me think about, which I would like to write more about: one is the idea of hell itself, and what it has meant to me in my life. Another is the difference between conservative and progressive SF. But I have written enough here I guess. I might do supplemental posts another time.

Oh, but there is one thing I want to talk about, because this gave me pause before I started this novel. It is, as one of my lj feminist friends said, 'a bit rapey'. There is, you understand, a lot of grim stuff, which I personally had to struggle through. It did not give me a feeling of revulsion, like some of Banks previous works have; it did not make me feel creeped out. But it was nasty, as it was intended to be. People have to judge for themselves if they want to endure those passages. I personally think it was amply worth it.

(3 comments | Leave a comment)

Comments:


[User Picture]
From:andrewducker
Date:November 6th, 2010 12:15 pm (UTC)
(Link)
The one thing I was not convinced by was that Lededje arrives on the Culture ship, and then goes out immediately and picks someone up that night to sleep with. Which doesn't strike me as a likely reaction of someone whose main connection to sex up until that point has been rape/slavery. That she was later revealed to have had a consensual relationship helped somewhat, but I, personally, would have liked to have seen more of the emotional/traumatising effect on her of her upbringing.
[User Picture]
From:communicator
Date:November 6th, 2010 12:19 pm (UTC)
(Link)
Yes, I wouldn't like to defend that particular plot choice, and it wasn't really necessary for the story either.
[User Picture]
From:andrewducker
Date:November 6th, 2010 12:21 pm (UTC)
(Link)
I hadn't thought about its necessity, but you're completely right, she could have gone out investigating the ship just as well without it being to pick someone up.

> Go to Top
LiveJournal.com